Comparison of motion RAO using MIT/NREL TLP file

Dear OpenFAST community,

  • I am using the 5MW_TLP_DLL_WTurb_WavesIrr_WavesMulti file for simulation in OpenFAST.
  • I am trying to comparison of motion RAO (Figure 26-RAO WAMIT 27m) calculated by Denis Matha in “Model Development and Loads Analyis of an Offshore Wind Turbine on a Tension Leg Platform, with a Comparison to other Floating Concepts”.
  • The way I do it is calculating motion RAO using white noise spectrum, with reference to the paper("Investigation of Response Amplitude Operators for Floating Offshore Wind Turbines) and forum posts
    [Method]
    I used 8000 seconds out of a 10000second simulation.
    wave time series → Sxx (spectral density ) using Blackman-Tukey
    ouput response(surge, pitch) → Sxy (spectral density) using Blackman-Tukey
    motion RAO = Sxy/Sxx
  • For surge motion RAO, I think the peak values match and y(RAO)-values for each frequency appear to be influenced by smoothing.
    However, For pitch motion RAO, the magnitude of the peak values varies significantly.

Is there something I am forgetting or doing wrong?
Please give suggestions on how to analyze.

Thank you for your help in advance.